Nantucket is an island located 30 miles off the south coast of Cape Cod, Massachusetts. With over 82 miles of beautiful coastline, dune-backed beaches, and a historic downtown, there’s a lot to enjoy on this elbow-shaped speck of land in the Atlantic Ocean!
This island is a picture-perfect example of a historic seaside town, complete with a ferry, 18th-century lighthouses, and a maritime history dating back 400 years.
In the late 1600s, whales were found off the shores of the island, and from then until 1840, Nantucket was a major whaling port. With the decline of that industry in the mid-19th century, Nantucket emerged as a favorite summer vacation destination among New Englanders.
Nantucket translates into the “Faraway Land” from the Wampanoag language. It truly feels like its own little world, a place where you can slow down and just enjoy the moment – whether that moment is biking on cobblestone streets, surfing in the Atlantic, or dining on the wharf.
With so many things to see and do, you’ll want a comfy place to come back to after a long day. Luckily, Nantucket is dotted with beautiful inns, historic boutique hotels, and luxurious seaside resorts. So many, in fact, that you might have a hard time choosing the perfect one. So we’ve created a list of the 12 best hotels in Nantucket to help you plan your perfect island getaway!
Don’t forget to check out our web story: The 12 Best Boutique Hotels in Nantucket
Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase or booking through one of our links we may earn a small commission (don’t worry, it’s at no extra cost to you).
Where to stay in Nantucket
On this 14-mile-long island, you’ll find that there is really only one consideration to make in deciding where to stay: downtown or in a more remote seaside location. You can’t go wrong either way!
In the town of Nantucket, you’ll find some of New England’s most unique boutique inns, interesting art galleries, and excellent restaurants. The historic architecture and cobblestone streets make every stroll feel magical. Plus, you’ll be steps away from the ferry terminal and the bustling wharves, as well as the historic 1746 Brant Point Lighthouse.
Getting around town is easy. In fact, we’d recommend biking or just walking if you’re staying in the downtown area. Biking is a lovely way to explore this charming island, and you’ll find that many hotels offer complimentary bikes.
If you’re more inclined toward the quieter coastal areas, there are plenty of seaside resorts and inns to choose from that offer easy access to Nantucket’s many different beaches. The tiny town of Sconset is a popular place to stay in Nantucket and is lined with unique cottages and historic fishing shacks.
Located on the eastern end of the island, here you’ll find a range of sandy beaches and the beautiful Sconset Bluff Walk, as well as some of the most charming boutique hotels in Nantucket! Head south, and you’ll find Surfside Beach, which is one of the most popular Nantucket beaches for its excellent surfing and fishing.
No matter where you decide to stay, many hotels provide complimentary beach chairs, towels, and even beach toys, so you’ll be able to fully enjoy Nantucket’s beaches without packing much more than a swimsuit!
The 12 Best Hotels in Nantucket
1. Blue Iris
Located in downtown Nantucket, this 1800s vacation estate formerly belonged to a patroness of the arts and served as a salon and studio space for local artists. Since then, the Blue Iris has been reimagined as one of the best boutique hotels in Nantucket.
The estate is whimsically decorated with curated artwork, Portuguese designs, and a soft coastal color scheme. The aesthetic extends to the rooms where you’ll find Mediterranean details mingling with Portuguese-inspired wood trimmings.
You’ll love the unique furnishings in each space. Charming details like bed frames with funky upholstering, decorative fireplaces, and showers lined with hand-painted tiles are just a few of the surprises you might find in your room.
If you have trouble deciding between the many beautiful suites, the Deluxe King with Terrace room has a spacious outdoor seating area. This is the perfect place to enjoy a cup of coffee in the morning while soaking up the island breeze.
If you’re traveling with a larger group, the Deluxe Suite is an amazing option. One queen bedroom, a twin bedroom, and a separate living room with a daybed will give you plenty of space to stretch out in style.
The Blue Iris is the perfect stay if you’re looking for artful European charm and comfortable luxury in Nantucket.
2. Brass Lantern Inn
The Brass Lantern Inn is an elegant boutique B&B in Nantucket’s historic downtown. This is the place to go to experience traditional Nantucket hospitality in a classic setting.
The 17 suites in this inn are beautifully appointed with a mix of modern and classic styles. Expect plush beds and armchairs, vaulted ceilings with skylights, and relaxing coastal patterns and colors. Rooms are bright and spacious, and they’re particularly well-suited if you’re traveling with a family or a group.
You’ll love filling up on the lovely breakfast spread each morning, which includes fresh fruit, homemade baked goods, and locally roasted coffee. When the weather is nice, you can take it outside to enjoy on the patio or in the garden.
Another special perk of this inn is the afternoon tea, which features a variety of cookies and beverages that you can enjoy in your room or in the garden. It’s the perfect way to catch your breath after a morning of coastal exploration.
Outside, you’ll find yourself on the cobblestone North Water Street, just a short walk from the ferry terminals, the Whaling Museum, and the town’s best shops and restaurants.
3. Faraway Nantucket
If you’re looking for a unique boutique hotel in Nantucket, you’ve found it in Faraway Nantucket. Styled with a mix of luxurious amenities and the aesthetics of an “exotic sea captain” – a nod to the island’s maritime heritage – you’ll find there’s no place quite like this on Nantucket.
Expect colorful textiles, beautiful architectural details, and plenty of interesting artwork on the walls. Custom pieces and designs from artists across the country give the guest rooms a one-of-a-kind personality, both eccentric and traditional.
We love the attention to detail in every part of the guest experience, from the Le Labo bath amenities to the ultra-comfy beds. We personally love the Roberts House Deluxe King, which features oversized picture windows, high ceilings, and a separate seating area, perfect for your morning routine.
For extra-special occasions, the Federal Suite offers the most privacy and space for your island getaway. A chef’s kitchen and wet bar make this a perfect entertaining space. Plus, you’ll get three bedrooms to really stretch out in.
We recommend reserving your room months in advance. Faraway Nantucket is one of the most popular places to stay in Nantucket and is usually fully booked!
4. The Wauwinet
This oceanfront luxury hotel is the best of its kind in Nantucket. Located near Great Point Beach to the north of the island, The Wauwinet offers a blend of historic charm and coastal elegance, along with spectacular views of the sea.
Staying here, you’ll have a choice between 32 luxurious guest rooms, spacious cottage suites, or the aptly named Anchorage House, which is perfect for big groups looking for a real home away from home.
We love the cottage suites for that little bit of extra privacy. The Idlewild Cottage Suite is perfect for a special occasion. It’s a beautiful one-bedroom cottage with a porch and a spacious living room with a gas fireplace.
The best amenity The Wauwinet offers is access to two private beaches right on the Atlantic Ocean. The hotel offers bikes, beach towels, chairs, and umbrellas for all guests, so you’ll have everything you need for a day out on the coast. You can even rent kayaks and paddleboards if you want to get out on the water!
Luxury features that you won’t find at other hotels in Nantucket also include the Pre-Arrival Concierge, who can help you arrange the perfect island activities like a lobster expedition, natural history hike, or wildlife tour.
5. White Elephant Hotel
The White Elephant Hotel is widely regarded as one of the best hotels in Nantucket – and for good reason! You’ll get to choose from many different styles of accommodation based on your travel needs, each complete with luxurious touches, first-class amenities, and plenty of island charm.
The White Elephant is a great choice if you’re in Nantucket for a longer stay or with a large group. This resort features classic hotel guest rooms and larger suites, but it also boasts a collection of garden cottages, fully-serviced downtown lofts, and a charming inn.
We love the garden cottages. These are perfect if you want to have a quintessential island getaway, taking tea on the balcony overlooking the flowers before heading off to nearby Children’s Beach.
For those who want the luxury of a full-service hotel coupled with privacy and space in the heart of Nantucket’s downtown, look no further than the spacious luxury lofts. You’ll be tucked away from the hustle and bustle, but all White Elephant amenities will still be available to you.
Those amenities include an outdoor heated pool, courtesy vehicle service, and priority spa services. This resort is also perfect for those traveling with little ones. They’ll be spoiled with special perks like check-in gifts, games, beach toys, and strollers, among many other offerings!
6. Carlisle House Inn
This three-story inn is over 250 years old and was formerly the home of a whaling captain. Carlisle House Inn now stands proud as an incredible monument to the island’s rich history, and it’s a truly unique place to stay in Nantucket.
Rooms are decorated with subtle nautical details, a nod to the inn’s past life. You’ll love the driftwood features, woven bed frames, and rich blues that come together to create a sense of coastal harmony.
We personally love the Sconset Suite. This room has two unique features: a functioning fireplace and a spacious bathroom with a deep soaking tub. It’s the perfect suite to get really cozy, especially if you’re visiting in the colder months.
The plentiful continental breakfast includes a selection of cereal, breads, yogurt, and fresh fruit – all served in a bright and airy sunroom. You’ll also be within walking distance of the island’s best breakfast and brunch spots.
Other perks of this stay include the lovely hydrangea garden and fire pit. You can really get a slice of authentic island life and experience living history at this inn!
7. Hotel Pippa
Hotel Pippa offers the island’s sleekest guest rooms, and it’s well-situated in Nantucket’s historic downtown, steps away from exciting galleries, restaurants, and boutiques!
You’ll love the modern yet unconventional design choices on display in the rooms, which showcase original pieces by local Nantucket artists alongside mid-century stylings, minimalist furnishings, and classic island architecture.
The rooms are bright and airy, and each one is unique. Perfect for traveling with friends, the Two-Bedroom Suite features two bedrooms with plush queen beds and luxurious ensuites. You’ll love relaxing in your whirlpool tub before enjoying a movie in your spacious living room!
Aside from great style, the other benefits of staying at Hotel Pippa include locally-sourced continental breakfasts and complimentary beach chairs and towels.
Of course, the location is also prime. Right across the street, you’ll find the art at Kagan + Coe gallery and made-from-scratch pastries at Born and Bread Mercantile and Bakery, among many other local gems. Just ask your concierge for recommendations!
8. Life House Nantucket
With a unique concept and rich style, Life House Nantucket is one of the coolest hotels in Nantucket if you’re looking for an intimate, sun-soaked abode to enjoy Nantucket from.
Rooms are bedecked with botany-inspired patterns and details, which take inspiration from the island’s own flora. Expect bright windows, vintage-inspired furnishings, and bold architectural details.
There’s nowhere better to do a bit of writing than the classic raffia desk in the Deluxe King Room. A decorative fireplace and thoughtful ceiling details give the space depth and style. Custom scents by Diptyque Paris, Revival New York linens, and a Marshall speaker will help you get cozy in the best way.
If that’s not enough, beautifully appointed common areas in this space include a posh living room, an island-style fire pit, a breakfast nook, and a lovely garden area.
9. Nantucket Resort Collection
The Nantucket Resort Collection encompasses three iconic inns. These 17th-century buildings have been lovingly restored and are now some of the best luxury boutique hotels in Nantucket.
Each inn has a distinct aesthetic, and they’re all located near the historic downtown. Whether you’re here for the sand and surf or the island’s famous Main Street, there’s sure to be one that suits your needs.
Sherburne Inn has the perfect location in the historic town center, and the vintage stylings match the cobblestone streets just outside. Alternately, Chapman House offers modern vibrancy alongside classic bed and breakfast service.
But Regatta Inn is our personal favorite, with its luxurious appointments, including marble ensuite baths, hardwood flooring, and coastal sophistication in a spacious mansion.
Staying here affords great perks, too! A free shuttle service can ferry you around the island, and a drop-off service will make getting to the beach a breeze. Beach chairs, towels, and totes are all provided by the resort, too.
10. Union Street Inn
The classic Union Street Inn is one of the best hotels in Nantucket. A historic house-turned-inn, this luxurious hotel offers impeccable New England style with a European flair.
The 12 guest rooms at Union Street Inn each have unique charms. Rich patterns, calm pastels, and thoughtful artwork all come together to make this a memorable stay. No matter which you choose, you’ll get thoughtful touches like Matouk bathrobes, Malin + Goetz toiletries, and beach bags with towels, bottled water, and magazines.
Grand four-poster beds add elegance to the suites. We particularly like the No. 9 Corner Suite. The bedroom opens out through French doors into a separate sitting room, and a wood-burning fireplace will keep you warm through the seasons.
Wake up to the daily breakfasts (served in bed, at your request!) and brew some fresh coffee at the wet bar to enjoy in the secluded garden. To get off the beaten path, just look to the inn’s connected concierges for recommendations. You’ll be staying right at the intersection of historic and contemporary Nantucket!
11. Greydon House
Greydon House is perched right off a wharf in downtown. And like so many of the best hotels in Nantucket, this place was formerly the home of a sea captain! Now you’ll find it as a unique 20-room stay, exclusively designed by Roman and Williams, household names in the New York hotel industry.
The house’s best features include a peaceful English garden and a Venetian-inspired restaurant. Fittingly, you’ll be only minutes away from Nantucket’s famed Whaling Museum and the ferry terminal.
You’ll appreciate the attention to detail in every guest room, which all feature custom-designed beds, brass fixtures, and hand-painted Portuguese tiles.
These memorable rooms contain fun surprises, with old-world elements and Indian-inspired designs that recall the life of a well-traveled maritime captain bringing home goods from Asia, Europe, and the Middle East. Greydon House also operates private guest houses in town, in case you want that luxurious hotel touch, but in a home all your own.
Greydon House’s Via Mare restaurant offers small plates served in a tavern-style dining room. Ingredients are locally sourced, and the wine list is both extensive and eclectic. This place is not to be missed during your stay!
12. The Nantucket Hotel & Resort
Last but not least, we have The Nantucket Hotel & Resort, one of the best hotels in Nantucket that’s been in operation for over a century. This is the only hotel on the island that stays open year-round, so you can enjoy island life across the seasons.
The hotel’s long tradition is clear from the cozy personality of the guest rooms and the excellent hospitality you’ll find here. Rooms are furnished in a classic coastal style, complete with plush beds, harbor views, and colorful artwork.
Spacious rooms, some with private decks and balconies, are steps away from the incredible resort amenities. One, two, three, and even four-bedroom suites accommodate groups of all sizes. For a classic island getaway, you can even reside in a historic seaside cottage that features vintage tubs and refined furnishings.
You’ll find a state-of-the-art fitness and spa facility here, heated outdoor swimming pools, and quirky additions like an antique fire truck that can shuttle you around Nantucket!
That completes our list of the 12 best hotels in Nantucket! Did we miss any cool boutique hotels in Nantucket? Comment below so we can add them to the list!
Didn’t find the perfect Nantucket hotel? Try searching here:
Booking.comPlanning a trip to Massachusetts? Check out our favorite books and travel guides!
Frequently Asked Questions
If you’re looking for a unique boutique hotel in Nantucket, you’ve found it in Faraway Nantucket. Styled with a mix of luxurious amenities and the aesthetics of an “exotic sea captain” – a nod to the island’s maritime heritage – you’ll find there’s no place quite like this on Nantucket.
The White Elephant Hotel is widely regarded as one of the best hotels in Nantucket – and for good reason! The White Elephant is a great choice if you’re in Nantucket for a longer stay or with a large group. This resort features classic hotel guest rooms and larger suites, but it also boasts a collection of garden cottages, fully-serviced downtown lofts, and a charming inn.
The Nantucket Hotel & Resort, one of the best hotels in Nantucket that’s been in operation for over a century. For a classic island getaway, you can even reside in a historic seaside cottage that features vintage tubs and refined furnishings. You’ll find a state-of-the-art fitness and spa facility here, heated outdoor swimming pools, and quirky additions like an antique fire truck that can shuttle you around Nantucket!
Located in downtown Nantucket, this 1800s vacation estate formerly belonged to a patroness of the arts and served as a salon and studio space for local artists. Since then, the Blue Iris has been reimagined as one of the best boutique hotels in Nantucket. The estate is whimsically decorated with curated artwork, Portuguese designs, and a soft coastal color scheme. The Blue Iris is the perfect stay if you’re looking for artful European charm and comfortable luxury in Nantucket.
The Wauwinet, an oceanfront luxury hotel is the best of its kind in Nantucket. It offers a blend of historic charm and coastal elegance, along with spectacular views of the sea. The best amenity The Wauwinet offers is access to two private beaches right on the Atlantic Ocean. Luxury features that you won’t find at other hotels in Nantucket also include the Pre-Arrival Concierge, who can help you arrange the perfect island activities like a lobster expedition, natural history hike, or wildlife tour.
