The Best Hotels in Martha's Vineyard, Massachusetts

The 12 Best Hotels in Martha’s Vineyard

Located just off the coast of Cape Cod in Massachusetts, Martha’s Vineyard’s charming towns and sandy beaches are just begging to be explored. Whether you’re looking for a relaxing retreat or an epic weekend away with friends, you’ll absolutely love spending time in this incredible East Coast destination.

With ferry access to Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and New York, Martha’s Vineyard is an ultra-popular weekend getaway for New Englanders. Visitors flock here on summer weekends to treat themselves to a stay at one of the island’s historic inns, dine at sea-to-table restaurants, and soak in the island’s stunning natural beauty.

Explore Martha’s Vineyard, and you’ll come across wonderfully preserved 19th-century Victorian houses, picture-perfect lighthouses, and six charming towns. Outdoor enthusiasts will love biking along the island’s 125 miles of coastline and stopping off at popular beaches like Joseph Sylvia State Beach and Lighthouse Beach. 

If you prefer to do more than just sunbathing, you can go boating on Lake Tashmoo, go birdwatching in Long Point Wildlife Refuge, or watch the sun sink into the ocean from the Aquinnah Cliffs Overlook. When night falls, you’ll love letting loose in the island’s main towns of Edgartown and Oak Bluffs. Both are lined with excellent restaurants and buzzing bars perfect for a night on the town!

No matter how you decide to spend your days in Martha’s Vineyard, you’ll want a luxurious room to relax in. Luckily, Martha’s Vineyard is dotted with all sorts of historic inns, boutique B&Bs, and fun-filled luxury resorts. So many, in fact, that you might have a hard time choosing the perfect one. So we’ve created a list of the 12 best hotels in Martha’s Vineyard to help you plan your perfect getaway!

Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase or booking through one of our links we may earn a small commission (don’t worry, it’s at no extra cost to you).


Where to Stay in Martha’s Vineyard  

Where to Stay in Martha's Vineyard: Best Hotels

Measuring just 96 square miles, Martha’s Vineyard is a blissfully small island that takes just 45 minutes to drive around. So no matter where you decide to base yourself, you’ll never be too far from all of the island’s best attractions.

It’s no secret that most of the best hotels in Martha’s Vineyard are located in the quaint town of Edgartown. Located on the east end of the island, near Chappaquiddick Island, Edgartown was founded in 1642 and was a thriving whaling port in the 1800s. 

Fast-forward to today, and the town is brimming with impeccably preserved 19th-century cottages that once housed whaling captains. Not only will you find incredible B&Bs and charming inns in Edgartown, but Main Street is lined with excellent bars, restaurants, and galleries. Edgartown is the perfect base if this is your first time in Martha’s Vineyard.

Vineyard Haven and Oak Bluffs are both located toward the north of the island, just minutes away from the ferry station. This part of the island is popular among travelers for its excellent restaurants, charming hotels, and boutique shops. Plus, it’s super convenient if you don’t plan on taking a car to the island.

If you prefer to be away from the hustle and bustle of Edgartown and Oak Bluffs, head “up-island” to Aquinnah, Chilmark, or West Tisbury. Here you’ll have plenty of room to stretch out and surround yourself with nature.


The 12 Best Hotels in Martha’s Vineyard

1. The Sydney

Where to stay in Martha’s Vineyard Massachusetts: The Sydney
Photos: The Sydney

Located right in the heart of Edgartown, The Sydney is one of the best boutique hotels in Martha’s Vineyard if you want to be able to walk to galleries, bars, and restaurants. Plus, rooms at The Sydney are easily some of the most stylish in town, which doesn’t hurt!

Guest rooms in this boutique B&B are situated in the 19th-century Captain’s House and a more modern building. Choose a room in the Captain’s House, and you’ll get retro-style furnishings and decor, as well as ultra-plush beds, cute sitting areas, and large flat-screen TVs.

Alternately, rooms in the more modern building are sleek and refined and have everything you need for a comfortable stay. Think waffle kimono robes, wine glasses, and corkscrews. 

In the mornings, head down to the lobby cafe and patio, where you can fill up on the complimentary buffet breakfast. The spread includes a variety of quiches, scones, muffins, fresh fruit, yogurt, and more. 

The staff will also leave out coffee, tea, and water (sparkling and still) 24 hours a day. Go outside, and you’ll find a lovely patio where you can gather around the fire pit, pop open a bottle of wine, and socialize over a glass of wine or two!


2. Summercamp

Martha’s Vineyard Boutique Hotels: Summercamp
Photos: Summercamp

As the name implies, Summercamp is a carefree and luxurious getaway nestled in the Oak Bluffs neighborhood. Once a popular summer camp destination, the Summercamp building has been welcoming guests since 1879. Today, the boutique hotel pays homage to its summer camp roots while offering guests everything they could possibly need for a fun-filled getaway.

It’s impossible not to swoon at the magazine-worthy rooms. From compact Twin Bunk rooms to massive Water View King Suites, there’s something for all types of travelers.

No matter which you choose, you’ll love the eye-catching, mid-century style, 43-inch smart TVs, and cute extras like the Tivoli Bluetooth radios, waffle kimono robes, and Lather toiletries. Plus, all guests can take advantage of the Hospitality Stations, which have filtered still and sparkling water, Keurig coffee, and tea.

If you can manage to tear yourself away from your dreamy room, you can take in the harbor views from your deck chair, purchase Cracker Jacks and Dreamsicles from the Camp Canteen, or tap into your inner child with a game of Twister in the game room. If you’re looking for unique Martha’s Vineyard hotels, this is it!

Like this post?! How about...
The 15 Best Things to Do in Cape Cod

3. The Edgartown Inn

Boutique Hotels Martha’s Vineyard Massachusetts: The Edgartown Inn
Photos: The Edgartown Inn

Located 15 minutes from the ferry terminal in Oak Bluffs and across the street from the ferry in Edgartown, The Edgartown Inn is the perfect pick if you don’t plan on driving much (if at all) during your trip. You’ll also be able to walk and bike to all of Edgartown’s best bars, restaurants, and galleries, as well as the Edgartown Harbor Light and Fuller Street Beach.

There are 12 polished rooms to choose from, each outfitted with luxurious amenities and boho-chic touches. You’ll love the plush bed, large smart TV, and mini-fridge. Plus, rooms are all outfitted with thoughtful extras like complimentary Wi-Fi and Lather toiletries, as well as sumptuous waffle robes and cool Tivoli Bluetooth radios.

If you’re willing to splurge, the King Deluxe Balcony room is set on the third floor and offers a bit more space and a private balcony with ocean views. Whichever guest room you choose, you’ll also get complimentary parking and daily continental breakfasts. 

Once you’re ready to get out and explore, the ultra-attentive staff will give you all sorts of insider tips on the best things to see, do, and eat in Edgartown and beyond!


4. Hob Knob

Best Martha’s Vineyard Hotels: Hob Knob
Photos: Hob Knob

It’s no secret that Hob Knob Luxury Boutique Hotel & Spa is widely hailed as one of the best hotels in Martha’s Vineyard. Set in a 19th-century Gothic Revival home on Edgartown’s Main Street, this gem of a hotel has been hosting visitors for over 100 years.

You can choose from 17 beautifully decorated rooms, all filled with colorful touches, unique antiques and art, and tributes to coastal New England. You’ll love the plush king-size beds with Frette linens, deluxe ensuites with soaking tubs and organic toiletries, and mini-fridges with snacks and drinks.

If you’re traveling with your furry friend, book the pet-friendly Private Entrance Suite with Kitchenette. Not only will your pup be right at home, but you’ll have a handy kitchenette and living room where you can prepare basic meals and have relaxing movie nights.

Before you get your day started, be sure to enjoy Hob Knob’s complimentary organic breakfast. Once you’re ready to head out, the staff will arrange bike rentals, private boat excursions, and treatments at the onsite spa for a fee. If you do happen to be hanging around the hotel in the afternoon, take advantage of the excellent (and free!) afternoon tea.

Check Prices & Availability on Booking.com


5. Harbor View Hotel

Boutique Hotels Martha’s Vineyard Massachusetts: Harbor View Hotel
Photos: Harbor View Hotel

Dating back to 1891, Harbor View Hotel offers the perfect blend of historic charm and luxurious amenities. Plus, you’ll get sweeping views of Edgartown Harbor, Lighthouse Beach, and Edgartown Harbor Light right from the hotel. 

The entire property was given an extensive $15 million renovation in 2020, so expect everything to be modern, new, and top of the line. Explore the revamped grounds, and you’ll find a heated saltwater pool, chic private cabanas, and a state-of-the-art fitness center. 

You’ll also have access to complimentary golf cart shuttles, Mercedes-Benz vehicles, and bicycles to go to and from the beach and town. And when hunger strikes, you can enjoy fresh seafood dishes and fine wines at local favorite Bettini Restaurant.

The deluxe amenities extend to the guest rooms. From beautiful rooms with an ocean view to picture-perfect cottages with tons of space, the accommodation options cater to all sorts of travelers. No matter which you choose, you’ll get luxurious features, including Molton Brown bath products, Frette linens, Nespresso coffee machines, plush robes, and so much more!

Like this post?! How about...
12 Cool Boutique Hotels in Cape Cod, Massachusetts

6. The Christopher

Where to stay in Martha’s Vineyard Massachusetts: The Christopher
Photos: The Christopher

If it’s not obvious by now, Martha’s Vineyard is just brimming with stylish bed and breakfasts – and The Christopher is one of the best. Located in Edgartown, this beautiful 19th-century home has everything you need for a relaxing and memorable vacation.

Even the most standard rooms look like they belong in a magazine. You’ll love the mid-century modern furnishings, the 32-inch flat-screen TV, and the designer ensuite. Plus, these rooms boast thoughtful extras like waffle kimono bathrobes, blackout shades, and wine glasses, a corkscrew, and an ice bucket.

For the best room in the house, book the spacious Lark Suite, which features an ultra-comfy king-size bed, a 40-inch flat-screen TV, and two private balconies. 

In the mornings, you can get your day started at the breakfast bar in the lobby. The complimentary spread features all of your breakfast favorites, from baked egg dishes to crispy bacon and freshly baked cornbread. 

Plus, when you return home in the afternoons, you’ll be greeted by a lovely array of complimentary snacks. In the evenings, head outside, where the fire pit will keep you warm while you socialize over a glass of wine.


7. Charles and Charles MV

Cool Hotels Martha’s Vineyard Massachusetts: Charles and Charles MV
Photos: Charles and Charles MV

Located in Vineyard Haven in the north of the island, Charles & Charles MV is one of the best Martha’s Vineyard hotels if you want to have easy access to the ferry. Not only is the Vineyard Haven ferry terminal an easy 13-minute walk from this hotel, but you’ll be a short stroll from all of the restaurants and shops on Main Street, too. 

This intimate hotel offers just six guest rooms – which all vary in size. If you don’t plan on spending too much time in your room, the Chilmark offers 225 square feet of space, as well as a handy coffee maker, mini-fridge, and deluxe toiletries. Or, if you prefer to have all the creature comforts of home, the Vineyard Haven Suite offers 375 square feet of space and a full kitchen, a separate living room, and a small patio. 

All guests get complimentary poolside breakfasts each morning, Wi-Fi, and use of the hotel’s bicycles. Plus, when you’re not out biking around Martha’s Vineyard, you can lounge around the seasonal pool or relax in the lovely gardens.

Check Prices & Availability on Booking.com


8. The Oak Bluffs Inn

Unique Martha’s Vineyard Hotels: The Oak Bluffs Inn
Photos: The Oak Bluffs Inn

Yet another historic gem in the heart of Oak Bluffs, The Oak Bluffs Inn is the perfect pick if you’re craving an intimate inn-style stay. Housed in an 1870 Victorian home, this charming inn has attracted A-list celebs over the years, including Woody Harrelson, bell hooks, and Spike Lee.

The inn boasts 10 beautifully decorated rooms, which are all totally unique. From child-friendly rooms to fully equipped family-friendly suites to romantic hideouts, there’s something for every type of traveler. 

No matter which one you want, you’ll get thoughtful extras like Aveda bath products and Italian Frette linens. All guests can also enjoy complimentary snacks and beverages, off-street parking, Wi-Fi, and daily continental breakfasts. 

While there is no on-site restaurant, owners Rhonda and Erik Albert are Martha’s Vineyard experts who love letting guests in on where to find the best bars and restaurants on the island! When it comes to customer service, The Oak Bluffs Inn is easily one of the best Martha’s Vineyard hotels you’ll come across.

Like this post?! How about...
The 15 Best Things to do in Boston

9. Edgar Hotel Martha’s Vineyard

Unique Hotels Martha’s Vineyard Massachusetts: Edgar Hotel Martha’s Vineyard
Photos: Edgar Hotel Martha’s Vineyard

Tucked away on Upper Main Street, Edgar Hotel Martha’s Vineyard is less than a mile from the center of Edgartown. With modern rooms and thoughtful extra amenities, you’ll have everything you could possibly need for a quintessential Martha’s Vineyard stay!

You’ll love all of the freebies, which include Wi-Fi, outdoor parking, and weekday newspapers. There’s also an on-site restaurant where you can enjoy lunch and dinner if you don’t feel like going into town. Plus, there’s a grocery store right next door, perfect for picking up snacks and supplies to bring back to your room. 

The modern rooms all boast coastal charm and modern amenities. You’ll love watching your favorite HBO shows on the 40-inch flat-screen TV, catching up with your emails at the ergonomic workstation, and luxuriating in the oversized walk-in shower. Plus, you’ll have in-room coffee makers to make your morning coffee and mini-fridges to store cold drinks and leftovers.


10. The Richard

Martha’s Vineyard Boutique Hotels: The Richard
Photos: The Richard

The Richard is located right on Main Street in the heart of Edgartown. Step inside, and you’ll quickly understand why this is one of the most popular places to stay in Martha’s Vineyard! Not only is every corner of this boutique inn picture-perfect, but you’ll be a short stroll away from all of Edgartown’s galleries, shops, and restaurants – so the location can’t be beat! 

It’s impossible not to love the designer rooms. Even the most standard of rooms is adorned with stylish retro-modern decor and furnishings, plush queen-size beds, and 43-inch smart TVs.

If you’re in town for a special occasion, The Lark Suite is the best room in the house and boasts 520 square feet of space, two rooms and bathrooms, a living area, and a private balcony. 

In the mornings, you and your crew can fill up on The Richard’s seriously good breakfast. Expect a spread of locally sourced items from fresh-from-the-oven pastries to fresh fruit and frittatas. Plus, if the weather is nice, you can dine on the beautiful patio. The staff will also leave out freshly brewed coffee, tea, and homemade cookies in the afternoon. 

Like this post?! How about...
12 Cool Boutique Hotels in Boston, Massachusetts

11. Narragansett House

Where to stay in Martha’s Vineyard Massachusetts: Narragansett House
Photos: Narragansett House

If you’re looking for unique Martha’s Vineyard hotels, look no further than Narragansett House. Nestled between Oak Bluffs Town Beach and Inkwell Beach, you’ll be within walking or biking distance to pretty much everything Oak Bluffs has to offer.

With its bright blue, pink, and purple paint job, it’s impossible to miss this 1870s Victorian gem. Step inside, and you’ll find the perfect blend of cottage charm and modern amenities. Plus, you’ll love the beautiful guest rooms!

You can start each day with the spectacular (and totally free!) breakfast, which consists of freshly baked goods, farm-fresh fruits and berries, and gourmet tea and coffee. Ask the staff, and you can arrange to have a romantic dinner in the garden, a picnic lunch at the beach, or an afternoon tea on the cottage’s porch (for a fee). 

However you decide to spend your days, you’ll love relaxing in the inn’s luxe rooms in the evenings. If you’re on a romantic retreat, Room 1 (aka the Honeymoon Suite) boasts a plush king-size bed, a cozy sitting area, and a private balcony overlooking Union Chapel. Alternately, if you’d like more space, Room 11 is outfitted with a private entrance and a small kitchenette.


12. Winnetu Oceanside Resort at South Beach

Cool Martha’s Vineyard Hotels: Winnetu Oceanside Resort at South Beach
Photos: Winnetu Oceanside Resort at South Beach

Winnetu Oceanside Resort at South Beach is the perfect pick if you’re looking for a carefree getaway. This place has so many cool amenities you won’t have to step foot outside of this resort if you don’t want to!

Explore the sprawling 11-acre grounds, and you’ll find multiple outdoor swimming pools, tennis courts, a massive lawn with outdoor yoga classes and lawn games, a fitness center, and tons of family-friendly games. Plus, South Beach is just steps away if you just want to laze the day away on the white sands of Martha’s Vineyard. 

Depending on the size of your crew, you can choose from standard guest rooms, one- to four-bedroom suites, and one- to two-bedroom cottages. Depending on which option you go for, you’ll get cool amenities, from full kitchens and private decks to deluxe living rooms and spa-like baths. 

If you can manage to tear yourself away from Winnetu Oceanside Resort, the resort’s complimentary shuttle is ready to whisk you to all of the shops and restaurants in Edgartown. Spending an evening wining and dining in town is the perfect way to end the perfect day in Martha’s Vineyard!

Check Prices & Availability on Booking.com

That completes our list of the 12 best Martha’s Vineyard hotels! Did we miss any cool boutique hotels in Martha’s Vineyard? Comment below so we can add them to the list!


Didn’t find the perfect Martha’s Vineyard hotel? Try searching here:

Booking.com

Planning a trip to Massachusetts? Check out our favorite books and travel guides!


SHARE THIS ON PINTEREST


0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Scroll to Top
18 Shares
Share
Pin18
Tweet